HSBC a reminder not all emerging markets are equal

By George Hay, Reuters Breakingviews Published: 9:36PM GMT 01 March 2010

HSBC Hldgs

The tellurian bank"s shares fell 5 per cent by lunchtime in London after 2009 pre-tax distinction came in next expectations. HSBC retains transparent advantages over the peers, but last year"s formula were a curate"s egg great in parts, but not all satisfactory.

HSBC stays commendably well-capitalised and funded. In noted contrariety to peers, it has almost some-more deposits than loans, a incident that softened in 2009. It additionally generated $10.2 billion in collateral during the year. Just over half of this paid for the dividend, whilst the rest was used to progress the bank"s core harvesting machine one capital, that increasing by 90 basement points to 9.4 per cent. That will assistance ensure opposite regulatory uncertainties or account acquisitions.

Questor share tip: Hold HSBC usually a ridiculous financier would bar it HSBC pays tip bankers some-more than �9m each HSBC"s Stuart Gulliver gets �9m reward To equivocate pensions penury, follow Goethe: whatever you can do, begin you do it Apples new MacBook: Review of reviews A-level results: how to get beheld in the pursuit marketplace

But HSBC"s expansion story depends on faster-growing rising markets creation up for low or loss-making operations in the West. That didn"t occur last year. Pretax distinction in the Asia-Pacific segment fell 8 per cent year-on-year, as HSBC"s large deposition bottom weighed on the seductiveness margins. Latin American distinction forsaken 33 per cent, and the Middle East fell off a cliff.

Instead, HSBC"s strength was in alternative areas. Its investment promissory note multiplication generated a pretax distinction of $10.5 billion 3 times what it done in 2008. Meanwhile, supplies for bad loans in North America a long-running thorn in HSBC"s side fell by 6.5 per cent year-on-year. Yet even these splendid spots showed intensity for concern. Investment promissory note income fell twelve per cent in the last quarter. And nonetheless the U.S. consumer financial book is mostly in run-off, loan waste ticked up to $3.2 billion in the last entertain from $3 billion in the prior 3 months.

HSBC has relocated arch senior manager Michael Geoghegan to Hong Kong, and plans to list in Shanghai, suggesting it isn"t going to be dreaming by a couple of diseased quarters. The bank thinks the rising economies in that it operates will enhance by 6 per cent in 2010, compared with only 2 per cent for grown economies.

But with HSBC shares trade at 10 times Nomura"s foresee gain per share for 2010, and scarcely dual times foresee book value, investors design HSBC to interpret these luscious macro total in to higher distinction growth. The bank needs to begin proof the expansion story can broach in 2010.